Gumroad listing makeover: one product page, fixed in a single PDF

SellPolish reviews one Gumroad listing and sends you a PDF that diagnoses what's costing you sales, with a rewrite you can paste in straight away. It costs $19, and the PDF arrives within 24 hours, weekends included. If it doesn't help, you get a 14-day full refund.

Get my makeover · $19

What's in your makeover PDF

Every makeover covers the same eight things, so you know what you're paying for:

1. Diagnosis. The specific problems on your page, ranked by how much they're likely to matter, with the exact text or element we're pointing at.
2. A new title, plus alternates. One recommended title and two alternatives with different angles (for example, an outcome angle and a bundle angle).
3. A paste-ready description. A full rewrite in Gumroad's editor format: hook, what's inside, how it works, what you get, who it's for, and an FAQ. Anything we can't verify is left in [BRACKETS] for you to fill in.
4. 3 cover ideas. Three concepts for your cover and thumbnail, sized for Gumroad. Gumroad recommends cover images of at least 1280 × 720 px and thumbnails of at least 600 × 600 px, and allows up to 8 covers per product (Gumroad Help: cover and thumbnail images).
5. 13 tags. Search phrases for your product's Discover tags and for your copy. Gumroad matches products in Discover partly by tags set on the Share tab (Gumroad Help: Discover).
6. Pricing vs comps. Your price compared with similar listings that are selling, and a recommendation. Price suggestions are clearly marked as estimates, not predictions.
7. Quick wins. The changes you can make in under an hour, in order.
8. A before/after table. A one-page summary of what changes and why.

You make the changes yourself. We never need your Gumroad login or any access to your account.

A real example (anonymised)

This is from a real sample makeover. We've removed the seller's name, store and product title. Read the full sample (PDF).

The listing: an AI prompt bundle on Gumroad. It had sales, zero ratings, and a price at the top of its niche.

What the diagnosis found:

• The numbers contradicted each other. The title, summary and description gave three different prompt counts and two different category counts. When buyers have to trust you, an inconsistency like that reads as made up.
• Two value anchors that disagreed. A struck-through "was" price, a different "total value" figure in the copy, and bonus "values" higher than the seller's own prices for those same items, which a buyer can click through and check.
• No social proof at a premium price. It cost about the same as established competitors that had many reviews.
• Buyers couldn't see inside. One cover image, no sample pages, and no format or page-count details.
• The title was a tagline, not a search phrase. It was about 140 characters, all caps, with the words people actually search for buried or missing.

Before vs after (summary table from the PDF):

The three quick wins it listed: make every number match (about 10 minutes); add inside-page images and fill in Gumroad's additional-details fields (about 20 minutes); ask past buyers for a rating (about 20 minutes). Gumroad already sends review reminder emails 5 days after purchase, and you can also email past buyers of one product directly (Gumroad Help: ratings and reviews).

We can't tell you what this did to sales. The changes are recommendations, and the report says the impact can't be predicted from public data.

See all three sample makeovers

Gumroad · AI prompt bundle

An AI prompt bundle

Dozens of sales, zero reviews, and three different prompt counts on one page. We made the numbers agree and showed buyers what's inside.

Read the sample (PDF, 8 pages)

Gumroad · Notion template

A Notion finance tracker

900+ sales but fewer than 10 ratings, and a title that read like a tag list. We gave it a real name and an easy way to try it first.

Read the sample (PDF, 8 pages)

Etsy · Google Sheets download

A couples budget spreadsheet

On page one of Etsy search, but not getting picked. We used the words buyers search for and led with the answer the sheet gives.

Read the sample (PDF, 8 pages)

Real listings, anonymised. Names, titles and figures have been changed to protect each seller.

How it works

1. Send your listing. Order at /buy/ and paste your Gumroad product URL. If you have anything you'd like us to know (who it's for, what's selling, what you've tried), add a line.
2. We review it against comparable listings. We read your page as a first-time buyer would, then compare it with similar Gumroad products that are selling.
3. You get the PDF within 24 hours, weekends included. Paste in the new copy, upload new covers when you're ready, and work through the quick wins.
4. Need a change? Ask for 1 free revision within 7 days of delivery.

Price

$19 per listing: one product, one PDF, delivered within 24 hours (weekends included). One order covers one listing on either Gumroad or Etsy.

Refunds and revisions: 14-day full refund, plus 1 free revision within 7 days. If the makeover isn't useful, email hello@sellpolish.com within 14 days and we'll refund you in full. If something needs adjusting, ask within 7 days of delivery and we'll revise it once for free.

Multi-listing bundles and a monthly plan are coming soon. For now, each makeover covers one listing.

Who this is for (and who it isn't for)

Good fit:

• Your Gumroad product gets views (check Analytics → views and conversion) but few or no sales.
• You're about to launch and want a second pair of eyes before you share the link.
• You've rewritten the page yourself a few times and can't tell what's wrong any more.

Not a good fit:

• Your product page gets almost no views. That's a traffic problem, and a better page won't create visitors. Read Gumroad product not selling: traffic problem or page problem? first.
• You want guaranteed sales or rankings. Nobody can honestly promise that.

What a makeover can't do

Gumroad is mostly a checkout and storefront. Most sellers bring their own buyers. Discover can recommend products, but only after your account and product meet Gumroad's requirements, which include at least $100 in genuine sales, a risk review, a selected category and ratings turned on (Gumroad Help: Discover). A makeover helps the visitors you already get decide faster. It doesn't replace sharing your work where your buyers are.

FAQ